Abstract： Objective To investigate videoassisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) and percutaneous catheter occlusion (PCO) in interruption of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA), in order to achieve minimally invasive surgical injuries and better clinical results. Methods From November 1995 to September 2009, 312 cases of PDA were treated in Fujian provincial hospital, among whom 252 patients were interrupted with VATS(VATS group) and 60 patients with PCO technique(PCO group). For the VATS group, there were 78 males and 174 females aged from 7 d to 31 years old (9.16±8.91 years), while there were 17 males and 43 females aged from 4 to 57 years old (25.55±14.10 years) in the PCO group. We used titanium clip to interrupt PDA under videoassisted thoracoscope for patients in the VATS group, and adopted Amplatzer method for patients in the PCO group. The clinical results, complications and hospital cost in the two groups were compared in this study. Results In the VATS group, all the PDA were successfully interrupted with no residual shunt. In the PCO group, 5% (3/60) of the patients had minor residual shunt after the procedure. No mortality occurred in both groups. Time of the procedure and hospital stay in the PCO group were shorter than that in the VATS group (70.20±31.20 min vs. 112.50±16.30 min, t=6.344,P=0.002; and 4.70±2.20 d vs. 6.50±2.80 d, t=3.241, P=0.022, respectively). However, the hospital cost for each patient in the PCO group was much higher than that in the VATS group (23 222.00±4 333.40 yuan RMB vs. 8 904.50±2 634.60 yuan RMB,t=25.360, P=0.000). Conclusion Compared with PCO, VATS in interrupting PDA can achieved not only excellent clinical results, especially in the newborn and baby cases, but also very satisfying cost which is just a little more than one third of the PCO cost.
目的 观察和评价采用偏心型封堵器导管介入治疗干下型室间隔缺损的近期疗效和安全性。 方法 2011年8月－12月，6例经无主动脉瓣脱垂的干下型室间隔缺损（直径≤7 mm）患者（年龄＞3岁）在杂交手术室接受介入治疗。造影评估后，建立动静脉轨道，在保留导丝的情况下置入合适型号的国产偏心型室间隔缺损封堵器，并于术后定期随访复查。 结果 6例患者缺损直径4～7 mm（平均5.3 mm），其中5例成功地接受了导管介入封堵治疗，置入封堵器直径5～9 mm（平均6.4 mm）。仅1例因封堵器置入后出现主动脉瓣受压影响关闭，即改由外科微创经胸封堵成功。所有患者在随访期内，无栓塞、残余分流、瓣膜功能障碍、房室传导阻滞、死亡等并发症。 结论 无主动脉瓣脱垂的干下型室间隔缺损患者接受导管介入封堵治疗是安全、可行的，且短期随访结果良好。
Objective A meta-analysis was performed for a comparison of outcomes between transcatheter closure and transthoracic closure for simple congenital heart diseases (CHD). Methods Electronic databases, including PubMed, EMbase, Scopus, CNKI, Wanfang Data and Weipu Data were searched systematically for the literature aimed mainly at comparing the therapeutic effects for CHD administrated by transcatheter closure and transthoracic closure. Corresponding data sets were extracted and two reviewers independently assessed the methodological quality. The meta-analysis was conducted with Revman 5.3. Results Twelve studies meeting the inclusion criteria were included, involving 8 studies regarding to atrial septal defect (ASD), 2 studies regarding to ventricular septal defect (VSD) and 2 studies with regard to patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). A total of 1 423 patients were included. It was observed that compared with transthoracic closure, transcatheter closure entailed a lower complication rate (OR=5.62, 95%CI 2.78 to 11.36, P<0.001). However, meta-analysis of operative success rate(OR=1.65, 95%CI 0.92 to 2.98, P=0.09), instantly (OR=0.75, 95%CI 0.40 to 1.41, P=0.37) and long-term (OR=0.72, 95%CI 0.25 to 2.05, P=0.54) persistent shunt after surgery showed no significant differences between two approaches. No publication bias was found according to the funnel plot of complication rate and operative success rate. Conclusion In the treatment of simple CHD such as ASD, VSD and PDA, compared with transthoracic closure, a lower complication rate were associated with transcatheter closure. Meanwhile, operative success rate, instantly and long-term persistent shunt after surgery were not statistically different between the two surgical approaches. However, this study was based on retrospective studies, the level of evidence remained low. More large sample size randomized controlled trials should be designed to explore the safety and effectiveness of these two approaches in the treatment of CHD.
Currently, transcatheter intervention is the preferred treatment for patients with anatomically suitable atrial septal defects. However, the use of nickel-titanium alloy occluders in interventional procedures results in lifelong presence of the implant in the body, leading to complications such as metal allergies and arrhythmias in some patients. To overcome the short-term and long-term complications associated with the presence of metal, and to avoid radiation exposure and metal toxicity, this paper reports a case of successful transcatheter closure of atrial septal defect in a pediatric patient with metal allergies using fully biodegradable occlude under ultrasound guidance, achieving excellent results by interventional therapy.