Objective To compare the results of plate and Kirschner wire fixation in treatment of nonunion of clavicular fracture. Methods From September 1991 to January 2002, 19 patients (9 with plate and 10 with Kirschner wire) were treated. The results were evaluated by reduction, bone union time, recovery of joint function, pain, and correction of deformation. Results The follow-up time was 6-23 months with an average of 11 months. Bone union -occurred after a mean time of 11 weeks. In plate group, 7 patients gained excellent results, 1 good and1 fair. In Kirschner wire group, 3 patients gained excellent results, 3 good, 3 fair and 1 poor. The result of plate is significantly better than that of Kirschner wire fixation(Plt;0.05). Conclusion Plate fixation is a good simple method for treatment of nonunion of clavicular fracture.
ObjectiveTo investigate the management strategies of clavicular fracture combined with brachial plexus injury and its effectiveness. MethodsBetween January 2006 and January 2012, 27 cases of clavicular fracture combined with brachial plexus injury were treated. There were 18 males and 9 females, aged 18-42 years (mean, 25.3 years). The causes of injury were traffic accident in 12 cases, falling from height in 10 cases, bruise in 3 cases, machinery injury in 2 cases. According to the Robinson classification, the clavicular fractures were rated as type Ⅰ in 2 cases, as typeⅡin 20 cases, and as type Ⅲ in 5 cases; there were 12 cases of total brachial plexus root avulsion injury, 10 cases of bundle branch injury, and 5 cases of hematoma formation and local nerve compression or injury. The injury to operation time was 6 hours to 14 days (mean, 4 days). Brachial plexus injury was repaired by epineurium neurolysis, nerve anastomosis, or nerve transposition after the exploration of the plexus; and fracture was fixed after open reduction. Sensory grading standard (S0-S4) by UK Medical Research Council (MRC) was used to evaluate the recovery of sensory function, and muscle strength grading standard (M0-M5) by MRC to evaluate the innervating muscle strength. ResultsThe incisions healed by first intention. All patients were followed up 18-36 months (mean, 26.3 months). All fracture achieved cl inical healing at 12-17 weeks (mean, 15 weeks). No complication of loosening or breakage of internal fixation occurred. The patients had no pain of shoulder in abduction. At 18 months after operation, the shoulder abduction was more than or equal to 60° in 8 cases, 30-60° in 8 cases, and less than 30° in 11 cases. The recovery of biceps muscle strength was more than or equal to M3 in 18 cases and less than M3 in 9 cases; the recovery of wrist flexion or flexor muscle strength was more than or equal to M3 in 13 cases and less than M3 in 14 cases. The sensory function recovery of median nerve was S3 in 14 cases, S1-S2 in 9 cases, and S0 in 4 cases. The shoulder abduction, elbow and wrist flexor motor function did not recover in 2 patients with total brachial plexus root avulsion injury. ConclusionIt is beneficial to the recovery of nerve function to early repair of the brachial plexus injury by exploration of the plexus combined with open reduction and fixation of clavicular fractures, the short-term effectiveness is good.