ObjectivesTo systematically evaluate the structure, publication type and contents of current guidelines for guideline development, so as to provide methodology references for guideline development in China. MethodsSix biomedical research literature databases, six guideline databases and 18 websites of academic institutions and health administrative departments were searched to locate guidelines for guideline development. We included the latest versions of guidelines from guideline development departments or academic institutions. We extracted information consisting of general guideline information, structure, principles, methods and procedure of guideline development. A descriptive analysis was conducted to analyze the general information, structure, principles, methods and procedure of guidelines among different guidelines for guideline development. ResultsAmong all the included 25 guidelines for guideline development published from 1998 to 2014, 50% of them were from North America. Structure of these guidelines were similar while detail levels of recommended guideline development methods and procedures were slightly different. The guideline development groups, systematic literature search, evidence assessment and recommendation formulation were vital part of guideline development. The ineffective promotion and implementation of guidelines for guideline development were common problems of current guidelines. ConclusionsProcedures recommended by current guidelines for guideline development are almost the same, but the methods and statements are different. We could develop our own guideline for guideline development based on the current relative high-quality guideline in order to provide guidance to the clinical guideline development in China.
ObjectiveTo build the list of appropriate dosage forms and specifications of essential medicines for children which is subsistent abroad and absent in China. MethodsBased on the authoritative data and expert consultation, we established the selection methodology which included the standard of essential medicine for children, the standard of appropriate dosage for children, the standard of appropriate specifications for children, the standard of urgent classification, the standard of urgent level. ResultsThe list of appropriate dosage forms and specifications included 61 medicines which included 20 dosage forms and 112 specifications. 112 specifications included 27 specifications which belong to level Ⅱ, and 85 specifications which belong to level Ⅲ. ConclusionThe established list can be included by the green channel.
ObjectiveTo investigate the type, development time, regional distribution, development methods, structure and contents of therapeutic drug monitoring (TDM) guidelines, so as to provide references for the development of TDM guidelines in China. MethodsGuidelines concerning TDM were electronically retrieved in PubMed, Ovid-EMbase, CNKI, VIP, CBM, WanFang Data, NGC (National Guideline Clearinghouse ), GIN (Guidelines International Network), World Health Organization (WHO) guideline database, official websites of governments and societies associated with TDM from inception to October 2015. Two reviewers independently screened literature, extracted data including basic characteristics, formulation methods and text structure, etc.. Then a descriptive analysis was conducted. ResultsA total of 37 guidelines concerning TDM were included, which involved 4 guidelines for management of TDM, 32 for technical practice and 1 for both of them. The results of analysis showed that: for the integrity of reporting items of guidelines, three (75%) management guidelines ranked grade A, but only 1 (3.13%) technical guidelines ranked grade A. The management specifications of TDM included four aspects as follows: standard terminology, the process specification, quality control and personnel qualification. The recommendations to TDM technology of specific drugs included evidence of TDM, standards and procedures, and personnel qualification. ConclusionThere is a rapid but unbalanced development for abroad TDM guidelines. Most of them are TDM technical guidelines. Evidence-based methods are suggested to be used to develop local TDM guidelines, especially for commonly used medicines and technologies without supporting of existed guidelines.