Objective To analyze and compare the effectiveness of the closed reduction with elastic intramedullary nail ing and open reduction with Kirschner wire fixations in the treatment of O’Brien type III radial neck fractures in children. Methods Between November 2007 and November 2010, 31 children with O’Brien type III radial neck fractures were treated by the closed reduction with elastic intramedullary nailing fixation (closed reduction group, n=18) and by the open reduction with Kirschner wire fixation (open reduction group, n=13). There was no significant difference in age, gender, disease duration, and fracture classification between 2 groups (P gt; 0.05). Results The incisions of 2 groups healed primarily. Allthe patients were followed up 1-2 years (mean, 1.5 years). Limitation of the elbow extension occurred in 2 cases of the closed reduction group, l imitations of the elbow extension, flexion, and forearm pronation in 6 cases of the open reduction group. There was no significant difference in elbow flexion, extension, pronation, and supination between affected side and normal side in the closed reduction group (P gt; 0.05). Except in supination (P gt; 0.05), there were significant differences in flexion, extension, and pronation between affected side and normal side in the open reduction group (P lt; 0.05). According to Metaizeau’s grading criterion, excellent results were achieved in 16 cases and good in 2 cases in the closed reduction group; excellent results were achieved in 4 cases, good in 4 cases, fair in 3 cases, and poor in 2 case in the open reduction group; and there was significant difference between 2 groups (Z=3.435, P=0.001). The X-ray films showed anatomical reduction in 2 groups before removal of internal fixation; redisplacement occurred in 4 cases after removal of internal fixation in the open reduction group, no redisplacement occurred in the closed reduction group. There was no avascular necrosis of radial head and epi physes during follow-up. Conclusion Comparison with the open reduction with Kirschner wire fixation, the closed reduction with elastic intramedullary nailing fixation is a rel iable and good treatment for O’Brien type III radial neck fractures in children, because it has the advantages of minimal invasion, easy operation, stable fixation, early mobilization, and less complication.
ObjectiveTo assess the effectiveness of percutaneous Kirschner wire poking reduction and elastic stable intramedullary nailing fixation for treating severe displaced radial neck fractures in children. MethodsBetween November 2010 and August 2014, 17 children with severe displaced radial neck fractures were treated with percutaneous Kirschner wire poking reduction and elastic stable intramedullary nailing fixation. There were 13 boys and 4 girls with an average age of 8.7 years (range, 6-14 years). The right side was involved in 9 cases, and the left side was involved in 8 cases. The causes of injury were falling in all cases. The angular deformity at fracture was 64-102° (mean, 84°). According to the Judet classification, 7 cases were classified as grade ⅠVa and 10 cases as grade ⅠVb. The time from injury to operation was 4.2 days (range, 1-7 days). Metaizeau classification and Tibone-Stoltz elbow performance score were used to access the radiological and clinical results, respectively. ResultsThe operation time was 20-50 minutes (mean, 30 minutes). All incisions healed by first intention. The patients were followed up 12-46 months (mean, 20 months). All fractures healed at 2 months after operation. There was no complication of malunion, early epiphyseal closure, avascular necrosis, enlargement of the radial head epiphysis, cubitus varus and valgus deformities, or proximal radioulnar joint synostosis. One case had elbow extension limitation. At last follow-up, the elbow range of motion in flexion, extension, pronation, and supination showed no significant difference between affected side and normal side (P>0.05). The clinical results were excellent in 16 cases and good in 1 case, with an excellent and good rate of 100%. The angulation was 0-12° (mean, 3.7°) on the X-ray film; anatomic reduction or nearly anatomic reduction was obtained, and the radiological results were excellent in 13 cases and good in 4 cases, with an excellent and good rate of 100%. ConclusionPercutaneous Kirschner wire poking reduction followed by fixation with elastic stable intramedullary nailing is a simple, safe, minimally invasive, and effective method to treat severe displaced radial neck fractures in children.