Objective To compare the surgical outcome of surgical treatment for chronic pancreatic head mass pancreatitis combined with pancreatic duct stones. Methods Clinical data of 19 patients diagnosed as chronic pancreatic head mass pancreatitis combined with pancreatic duct stones by pathology in our hospital were analyzed retrospectively and patients were divided into Beger group (n=9) and Frey group (n=10) according to operation type. Results The duration of operation, blood loss, morbidity, ratio of postoperative pancreatic fistula of grade B, ratio of abdominal cavity infection, ratio of gastric emptying dysfunction, total length of hospital stay, and total hospitalization cost in Frey group were less or lower than those in Beger group significantly (P ＜0.05). None of death or pancreatic fistula of grade C happened in both 2 groups, and abdominal pain and jaundice were subsided in all patients. There were 18 patients (94.7%) were followed up for (8.6±2.5) years ( 5-12 years), and just 1 patient of Frey group was not available for followup. The ratios of 5-year pain subsided of 2 groups were both 7/9, there was no significant difference between the 2 groups (P>0.05). During the follow-up period, there was no dead, relapsed, cancerate or reoperation, but 2 patients suffered from diabetes (1 patient of Frey group and 1 patient of Beger group), 2 patients suffered from steatorrhea (1 patient of Frey group and 1 patient of Beger group), and there was no significant difference between the 2 groups in the ratios of diabetes and steatorrhea (P>0.05). Conclusion The effect is equal for Frey surgery and Beger surgery in treatment of chronic pancreatic head mass pancreatitis combined with pancreatic duct stones, but recover of patient who receives Frey surgery is better than that of Beger surgery.