ObjectiveTo investigate the effectiveness of individual percutaneous cannulated screws fixation of computer-assisted design combined with three-dimensional (3D) guide plate by comparing with cast immobilization and open internal fixation for treatment of Herbert type Ib scaphoid fracture. MethodsBetween January 2010 and June 2015, 56 patients with fresh Herbert type Ib scaphoid fracture were treated with cast immobilization in 16 cases (external fixation group), with open reduction and internal fixation in 20 cases (open reduction group), and with individual percutaneous cannulated screws fixation of computer-assisted design combined 3D guide plate in 20 cases (minimal invasion group). There was no significant difference in gender, age, injury cause, side, disease duration, and classification of fractures between groups P>0.05).The time of bone union, bone nonunion rate, return-to-work time, wrist range of motion (ROM), and Mayo function score were recorded and compared. ResultsPrimary healing of incision was obtained in open reduction group and minimally invasion group, without related complications. The cases were followed up 10-24 months (mean, 16.6 months). The time of bone union and return-to-work time of minimal invasion group were significantly shorter than those of the other 2 groups (P<0.05), and the rate of bone nonunion was significantly lower than that of the other 2 groups (P<0.05). At last follow-up, the wrist ROM of minimal invasion group[(104.40±3.46)°] was significantly larger than that of external group[(94.20±2.42)°] and open reduction group[(96.40±2.66)°] (P<0.05). According to Mayo function score, the results were excellent in 6 cases, good in 5 cases, fair in 2 cases, and poor in 3 cases in external fixation group, with an excellent and good rate of 69%; the results were excellent in 9 cases, good in 7 cases, fair in 2 cases, and poor in 2 cases in open reduction group, with an excellent and good rate of 80%; the results were excellent in 16 cases, good in 3 cases, and fair in1 case in minimal invasion group, with an excellent and good rate of 95%; there was significant difference in excellent and good rate among groups (P<0.05). ConclusionIndividual percutaneous cannulated screws fixation of computer-assisted design combined with 3D guide plate has satisfactory effectiveness in the treatment of Herbert type Ib scaphoid fractures, with the advantages of mini-invasion, high accuracy, high rate of bone union, less complication, early return-to-work time.